Next, the differences between TVS diodes, varistors, and suppressors are compared from various perspectives. The applications and features of each ESD protection element are also summarized.
The table below shows the differences in usage locations, application examples, advantages, and disadvantages for TVS diodes, varistors, and suppressors.
Varistors are ceramic-based ESD protection elements and are often used in power supply ports and data lines.
Note that while higher capacitance products have superior discharge characteristics, the large electrostatic capacitance of varistors renders them unusable on RF ports that require low-capacitance products of 0.5 pF or less.
In addition, while their low cost is an advantage, repeated ESD application can potentially cause degradation of insulation resistance (short-circuit).
Suppressors are ceramic-based ESD protection elements used for high-output RF ports (antenna ports) such as Wi-Fi® and Bluetooth®, as well as data lines, etc. Their extremely low capacitance of 0.1 pF or less makes them suitable as ESD countermeasures on high-speed signal transmission lines.
However, disadvantages compared to TVS diodes include the fact that ESD protection does not operate at low voltages, and the response speed is slow.
TVS diodes are semiconductor-based ESD protection elements and are used for ESD protection in data lines such as power supply ports, USB ports (USB 1.1 to USB 3.2) and HDMI ports (HDMI 1.0 to 2.0), low-output power RF ports such as NFC, and RF ports for receive-only GPS. (See "TVS diode usage examples" on the "TVS Diodes (ESD Protection Devices)" page for details.)
TVS diodes cannot be used in high-output RF ports like suppressors, but they exhibit high discharge characteristics on low-output RF ports and GPS antenna reception lines.
When ESD intrudes, TVS diodes have a fast response speed until operation in the order of picoseconds, which is a major difference and advantage compared to varistors or suppressors. Despite costing more than varistors or suppressors, they are used as protection from ESD for data lines that perform high-speed transmission in electronic devices equipped with high-performance and high-cost ICs.
TVS diodes respond on the order of picoseconds, the fastest among the three ESD protection devices.